Appeals & reviews

Buckinghamshire · Selection Review & appeals

Buckinghamshire:
review or appeal?

A Selection Review considers qualification. An admission appeal follows a refused place at a named school. Understand the choice, the deadlines and how one process affects the other.

Buckinghamshire · 2027 entry4 min readReviewed

Keep the CAF on time.

A Selection Review does not replace your secondary application. Include the grammar schools you want considered by 31 October 2026.

Find Buckinghamshire schools
In this guide

The decision after the result

121 is the Buckinghamshire qualifying score. Below it, the choice is about which process applies and what evidence you have. A result is not yet a refusal of a school place. The council’s results guidance sets out the options.

Selection Review

A written case about grammar-school suitability after a result below 121. Success gives qualified status across Buckinghamshire grammar schools; allocation still follows each school’s rules.

How to submit a review →

Admission appeal

A case about admission to a particular school after it refuses a place. You may wait for this route or appeal after an unsuccessful review, but the panel’s starting point differs.

How a previous review matters →

A separate pupil premium provision may also apply. Check the named school’s policy for its minimum score, eligibility evidence and any catchment condition. Buckinghamshire says this can be used alongside a Selection Review. Do not assume every child below 121 is considered under the same rules.

Dates and documents to keep together

These dates relate to September 2027 entry. A later result or exceptional late request needs the council’s specific instructions.

Test result9 October 2026
Read the score and qualification decisionSave the email and student ID, and keep the component scores with it.
Full review case30 October 2026
For results received on 9 OctoberThe initial request alone does not complete the review submission.
Secondary application31 October 2026
A separate deadlineApply through your home authority and name the grammar schools you want considered, alongside realistic alternatives.
Review outcome12 February 2027
For the main review periodKeep the decision with your original review evidence.
School offers1 March 2027
Read any refusal and appeal instructionsUse the published school appeal timetable; review dates are not appeal deadlines.

If you request a Selection Review

Use the official review instructions and speak to the headteacher promptly. There are two form stages: the request and then the full case. The council also seeks a headteacher summary. Check that the complete submission, including the evidence you intend to rely on, reaches the council in time.

  1. Academic informationUse relevant reports and teacher information to show the child’s usual attainment. Explain what each record establishes, rather than simply attaching everything available.
  2. Any exceptional circumstancesConnect the circumstances to the test date and result, with relevant supporting records. A description of a difficult day and evidence of academic suitability serve different purposes.
  3. The review recordKeep the forms, supporting documents, confirmation and final decision together. They may be relevant if a later school refusal leads to an appeal.

The council’s evidence instructions exclude samples of school work and extracurricular participation. Review those instructions before uploading documents. A review concerns qualification; it is not a place to rank preferred schools or make a school-capacity case.

How review affects a later appeal

For a child who remains non-qualified, the DfE’s selective-appeal guidance distinguishes whether a local review has already taken place.

No Selection Review
After a refusal, the panel considers evidence of the required academic standard and, where applicable, whether the child’s case outweighs the school’s case against admitting another pupil.
An unsuccessful Selection Review
The panel first considers whether the review was fair, consistent and objective. If it was, it does not rehear grammar-school suitability. If that requirement was not met, it can consider the remaining selective-appeal issues.

A successful review still does not guarantee an offer. If a qualified child is refused under the school’s oversubscription rules, read that refusal as a separate school-place decision.

Keep the allocated place while considering an appeal, record the school’s lodging and evidence deadlines, and prepare a separate case for each school. The appeal overview explains the hearing stages; the evidence guide helps organise the submission.

Common questions

A few things parents ask

Can I request a Selection Review and later appeal?

Yes, after a school refuses a place. An unsuccessful review changes the first question at the appeal: whether the review was fair, consistent and objective. It is not an automatic opportunity to repeat the academic case.

Does a successful Selection Review guarantee a place?

No. It gives the child qualified status for Buckinghamshire grammar schools. The schools named on the application still apply their admission rules to allocate places.

Can I wait for an appeal instead of requesting a review?

Buckinghamshire describes that option. Name the preferred grammar schools on the secondary application and wait for a refused place before lodging a school admission appeal. Read the council’s explanation before deciding between the routes.

What if the result arrives after 9 October 2026?

The council gives different timing for later results, normally a review request within three weeks of receiving the score, subject to its final cutoff and late-request rules. Follow the Selection Review page and your result communication.

Official sources

Reviewed 28 Sept 2026

  1. Buckinghamshire Council — test results and options
  2. Buckinghamshire Council — Selection Review
  3. DfE — advice for parents on admission appeals